Last reviewed on 12 September 2026.
NNWA publishes the name and qualifications of everyone who writes and checks its material. You can see the full teaching team on the faculty page.
This page compares the three on the measures that actually matter: calories per spoon rather than per 100 g, what each does to blood glucose, how much iron jaggery really supplies, and the two safety points that apply only to honey. Figures draw on Indian food composition data from NIN, USDA FoodData Central and WHO guidance on sugars.
What are jaggery, honey and sugar actually made of?
All three are mostly sugar, in slightly different forms. White sugar is nearly pure sucrose, crystallised from cane juice after the molasses has been refined away. Jaggery, or gur, is the same cane juice boiled down in open pans without that refining, so it keeps some molasses, moisture and minerals, but its sugar is still largely sucrose, commonly quoted at 60 to 85 per cent of its weight, with some glucose and fructose besides. Honey is nectar concentrated by bees: about four-fifths sugar, mainly fructose and glucose, and roughly 17 per cent water.
Which has the fewest calories per 100 g?
Honey, but only because it contains water. USDA FoodData Central lists honey at about 304 kcal per 100 g and white granulated sugar at about 387. Indian food composition data put jaggery at roughly 380 kcal per 100 g, fractionally below sugar because it holds more moisture and some non-sugar matter. Those gaps look useful on a nutrition panel and largely disappear once you measure by the spoon, which is how sweeteners are actually used. None of the three is a light food. Each is concentrated energy with very little else attached.
How many calories are in a teaspoon of jaggery, honey or sugar?
About 16 kcal for sugar, 15 to 19 kcal for grated jaggery and 20 to 21 kcal for honey. Honey jumps from lowest to highest because it is dense: a level teaspoon of granulated sugar weighs about 4 g, while the same spoon of honey weighs about 7 g. Replacing two spoons of sugar in tea with two spoons of honey therefore adds calories rather than saving them. Jaggery has its own trap. It is usually broken off a block rather than measured, and the piece that goes into chai or gets eaten after lunch is often two or three times the size of a teaspoon.
| Per teaspoon | Per 100 g | |
|---|---|---|
| White sugar | about 16 kcal | about 387 kcal |
| Jaggery, grated | 15 to 19 kcal | about 380 kcal |
| Honey | 20 to 21 kcal | about 304 kcal |
A level teaspoon of sugar weighs about 4 g and the same spoon of honey about 7 g, which is how honey moves from lowest to highest.
Does jaggery raise blood sugar less than white sugar?
Not reliably. Jaggery is still mostly sucrose, and the gut splits it into glucose and fructose exactly as it does with refined sugar. Published glycaemic index (GI) values for jaggery are few, vary with how the batch was made, and some come out as high as or higher than table sugar, which sits at about 65. The idea of gur as a slow sugar has no solid research behind it. The size of the portion does far more than the type of sweetener, and the guide to the glycaemic index of Indian foods explains why one ingredient's GI is a weak guide on its own.
Is honey better than sugar for diabetes?
No. Honey raises blood glucose, and a teaspoon of it carries a little more sugar than a teaspoon of the white kind. Its GI depends on the flowers the bees fed on: fructose-rich honeys test lower, others test high, and a jar rarely tells you which you have. For someone with diabetes, honey, gur and sugar share one small allowance, and switching between them does not enlarge it. The effort pays off far more in the staples, the dal and the size of the rice or roti portion, which is where the list of diabetes-friendly Indian foods puts its attention.
Does jaggery help with anaemia?
No, not in amounts anyone should eat. Published figures for jaggery's iron vary several-fold, from a couple of milligrams to around 11 mg per 100 g, and part of the higher values comes from the iron pans that traditional gur is boiled in. Even at the generous end, a 5 g teaspoon supplies about half a milligram, against the 29 mg a day that ICMR-NIN recommends for adult women. Eating enough jaggery to matter would mean eating a harmful amount of sugar. The foods that do move haemoglobin, and the vitamin C pairing that helps absorption, are set out on the page about iron-rich Indian foods.
Do the minerals and antioxidants in jaggery and honey count for anything?
They are real but small. Jaggery keeps some potassium, magnesium and calcium from the cane, and darker honeys carry polyphenols that give them their colour and sharper taste. A spoon of either delivers a sliver of what one katori of dal, a handful of greens or a piece of fruit provides. Choosing gur over sugar is a perfectly good decision on taste. It stops being good when the health halo takes over and a sweet labelled "made with jaggery" earns a second helping. Chikki, gur sandesh and jaggery laddoos remain sweets, whatever the packet implies.
Is honey with warm water and lemon good for weight loss?
No. Nothing in honey, lemon or warm water burns fat, and the honey adds about 20 kcal a teaspoon, or roughly 60 kcal for a tablespoon. The ritual can help a little if it replaces a sweeter chai or a couple of biscuits first thing, but any change on the scale comes from what it displaced. Warm water on waking is harmless, and some people find it helps their bowels move. Traditional advice also warns against stirring honey into boiling water, and there is no reason to: very hot water adds nothing and dulls the flavour you paid for.
Why must babies under one never be given honey?
Honey can carry spores of Clostridium botulinum, the bacterium behind botulism. An older child's or adult's gut stops the spores from growing, but an infant's gut cannot yet do so reliably, and the spores can germinate and release a toxin that causes infant botulism, a rare but serious paralysing illness. Warming the honey does not make it safe. That rules out honey on a pacifier, in home remedies for colic, and the custom in some families of placing a drop on a newborn's tongue. A baby under one who has had honey and then becomes constipated, weak or floppy, or feeds poorly, needs a doctor that day. After the first birthday, a small spoon of honey is a reasonable home remedy for a cough.
Is honey sold in India often adulterated?
Some of it has been. Indian investigations, including a widely reported one in 2020, found sugar syrups in honey samples from the market, some of them apparently made to slip past routine laboratory tests. FSSAI publishes a standard that honey must meet, but the checks require equipment no household has. The popular home tests, such as dropping honey into water, rubbing it between the fingers or trying to set it alight, cannot reliably separate pure from adulterated. Crystallisation is not a warning sign either, because many genuine honeys set solid in a cool kitchen. A seller you trust remains the most practical safeguard.
Are palm jaggery and coconut sugar any different?
Only slightly. Palm jaggery, which is karupatti in Tamil Nadu and nolen or patali gur in Bengal, comes from the sap of palms such as the date palm and the palmyra, and coconut sugar from the sap of coconut blossoms. Both are still mostly sucrose, with small amounts of minerals and the smoky caramel flavour that makes a Kolkata winter's sandesh and payesh what they are. Claims of a dramatically lower GI come mostly from sellers rather than independent testing. Brown sugar, for its part, is white sugar with some molasses added back. Enjoy nolen gur in season, as the treat it is.
Does it matter which one goes into chai, sweets or cooking?
Mostly for taste and texture. Jaggery gives the molasses depth that belongs in winter chai, chikki, til laddoo and the sweet-sour dals of Gujarat and Karnataka, though it can curdle milk if added to a pan that is still boiling, so many cooks stir it in off the heat. Honey scorches quickly and overwhelms delicate flavours, so it works better drizzled than cooked. White sugar is neutral and behaves predictably in syrups and mithai. Pick whichever suits the dish and then use less of it. For many people, the craving for strong sweetness fades after a few weeks of steady cutting back.
Using less of whichever one you keep
Which of the three you choose is a flavour decision. How much you use is the health decision.
Count where sweetener actually enters the day
Chai, the spoon in the morning glass of warm water, biscuits, mithai and the piece of gur after lunch. Most of it goes unrecorded.
Measure the spoon instead of breaking a lump
Jaggery is usually snapped off a block, and the piece that goes into chai is often several times the size of a teaspoon.
Cut back gradually rather than all at once
Taste adjusts over a few weeks, and the craving for strong sweetness fades with it.
Treat gur sweets as sweets
Chikki, til laddoo and gur sandesh do not become health food because of what sweetened them.
Pick the sweetener for the dish
Jaggery for molasses depth in winter chai, stirred in off the heat so it does not curdle the milk. Honey drizzled rather than cooked. White sugar where a syrup has to behave predictably.
How much jaggery, honey or sugar is reasonable in a day?
Less than most Indians currently eat. WHO advises keeping free sugars under 10 per cent of daily energy, and ideally under 5 per cent: for someone eating 2,000 kcal, that means below about 50 g a day and ideally nearer 25 g. Jaggery and honey count in that total exactly as white sugar does. The sibling page on how much sugar per day converts those limits into teaspoons and shows where sugar hides in Indian drinks, biscuits and breakfast foods.
Sweeteners, glucose and the people who ask about them
Questions like this one reach anyone who counsels people with diabetes or prediabetes almost daily, and a good answer needs more than a calorie table. NNWA's Diabetes and Metabolic Nutrition course covers blood glucose and metabolism, carbohydrates and glycaemic response, balanced Indian meal planning, weight and metabolic syndrome, how diet, activity and medication interact, and counselling for lasting change. Six weeks long and pitched at intermediate level, it costs 9,999 rupees against an original 14,999, payable as EMI of 1,667 rupees a month, and leads to NNWA certificates.
The honest summary
Jaggery, honey and white sugar are three routes to the same place. Per teaspoon, honey is slightly higher in calories and jaggery about level with sugar, and all three raise blood glucose. Gur's iron is too little to treat anaemia, and honey's reputation outruns its evidence. Choose among them for flavour, never give honey to a baby under one, buy honey from a source you trust, and put your energy into using less of whichever sweetener you keep in the kitchen.